The Call Her Daddy split is one of the best-known business breakups in podcasting - and at its core, it is a dispute about who owned what.
Sofia Franklyn's memoir, Daddy Issues, was released on 10 November 2026 and has put the story back in the headlines. The book tells her side of the falling out with co-host Alex Cooper. We are not here to take a side. But for anyone building a business with a friend, partner or co-founder, the public facts of what happened are a lesson worth 5 minutes of your time.
What happened
Two friends built a hit show, but neither of them owned it.
Cooper and Franklyn met in New York, became roommates and started Call Her Daddy together in 2018. The show was quickly picked up by Barstool Sports. Under that deal, Barstool reportedly owned the show's name and intellectual property, and the 2 hosts were paid a salary.
By 2020 the show was one of the biggest podcasts in the world. The hosts went back to Barstool to renegotiate for more money and a share of ownership. Those talks broke down, and so did the friendship. The 2 reportedly disagreed on how hard to push and whether to accept what was on the table.
In the end, Cooper signed a new deal with Barstool and kept the show. Franklyn left and later launched her own podcast, Sofia with an F. Cooper went on to take Call Her Daddy to Spotify in 2021 in a deal reported at around $60 million, and then to SiriusXM in 2024 in a deal reported at $125 million or more.
The brand both women built ended up with one of them, because the company that owned it chose who to back.
4 lessons for business owners
Every one of these problems is cheap to solve at the start and expensive to solve once the business is worth fighting over.
- Own your IP: The hosts created the content, the voice and the audience, but someone else owned the name. When the business is valuable, whoever owns the IP holds the leverage. Your brand, business name, domain, social accounts and content should sit in an entity you control, and that ownership should be documented.
- Put a co-founder agreement in place early: There appears to have been nothing between the 2 hosts deciding who keeps the brand if they part ways. Without that, the answer came down to who the platform wanted. A written agreement made while you are still friends removes that question.
- Agree on deadlock and exit before you need to: The split was really about different appetites for risk in a negotiation. Good agreements set out how decisions are made when founders disagree, what happens if one wants out, and how a departing founder's share is valued and paid.
- Be careful who is at the table: Outside advisers can be valuable, but make sure everyone advising the business is acting for the business, and that it is clear who has authority to negotiate on its behalf.
What this looks like for an Australian business
For most Australian co-founders, protecting yourself comes down to a handful of documents.
- Shareholders agreement: If you trade through a company, a shareholders agreement sets out how decisions are made, what happens on a deadlock, what happens if a founder leaves, and how shares are valued and transferred.
- Partnership agreement: If you run the business as a partnership, a partnership agreement does the same job. Without one, default rules apply that may not suit either of you.
- IP assignment: Content, logos, software and other work created by a founder is not always owned by the company automatically. An IP assignment moves it into the business so it stays there if a founder leaves.
- Business name, trade mark and domains: Registering a business name gives you no ownership of the brand. A registered trade mark does. Make sure the trade mark, domains and social accounts are held by the business, not by one person.
- Contracts with platforms and partners: Before you sign with a distributor, network, franchisor or major customer, check who will own what you create under that deal. Our commercial contracts team can review these before you commit.
Get it in writing while you are still friends
The best time to agree on who owns what is before the business is worth arguing about.
If you are starting a business with someone, or already in one without a shareholders or partnership agreement, Corporate Legal can help you put the right documents in place, from shareholders agreements and buy-sell agreements to reviewing the contracts you sign with partners and platforms. Get in touch with our team to talk through your situation.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Deal figures are as reported in the media.